Summary
The Elden Ring Tarnished Update has given players another reason to revisit the Lands Between, while the existing Smithscript weapon lineup remains an interesting choice for flexible builds. These weapons combine traditional melee combat with throwable attacks, giving players more ways to pressure enemies from different ranges. Players can also buy Elden Ring Runes to strengthen their characters. With Patch 1.17 bringing balance adjustments to several Smithscript weapons, it is worth revisiting which ones deserve a place in your build.
S Tier - Smithscript Dagger
The Smithscript Dagger takes the top spot thanks to its speed, range, and excellent utility. It scales across Strength, Dexterity, Intelligence, and Faith, making it easy to fit into hybrid builds. Its throwing attacks provide consistent ranged pressure, while its fast moveset works well against mobile enemies. Patch 1.17 also specifically buffed the Dagger, making it an even more attractive option.
A Tier - Smithscript Cirque
The Smithscript Cirque is arguably the most aggressive Smithscript weapon. As a Backhand Blade, it combines fast attacks with throwable options and the Blind Spot skill. Its four-stat scaling provides plenty of build flexibility. It may not be as universally useful as the Dagger, but skilled players can get excellent damage and mobility from it.
A- Tier - Smithscript Spear
The Smithscript Spear offers a strong balance between melee reach and ranged attacks. Its Impaling Thrust skill gives it reliable close-range pressure, while its throwing attacks let players maintain distance when needed. Patch 1.17 also improved the Smithscript Spear, raising its value for both exploration and boss encounters.
B Tier - Smithscript Greathammer
The Smithscript Greathammer delivers serious impact and benefits from Strength-focused builds, while still supporting throwable attacks. Its heavy weight and slower moveset make it less flexible than the Dagger or Cirque, but its damage and stagger potential can be excellent. It was also among the Smithscript weapons receiving buffs in Patch 1.17.
B- Tier - Smithscript Axe
The Smithscript Axe is fun and powerful in the right hands, especially for aggressive Strength builds. However, its slower attacks and more limited versatility keep it below the other options. Patch 1.17 improved the Axe, so it is now more competitive than its original reputation suggests.
C Tier - Smithscript Shield
The Smithscript Shield is the most niche option. Its Discus Hurl skill gives it unique ranged utility, but its overall damage and build flexibility make it harder to recommend as a primary weapon. Still, players who enjoy unconventional builds can have plenty of fun with it.
Final Ranking
S: Smithscript Dagger
A: Smithscript Cirque
A-: Smithscript Spear
B: Smithscript Greathammer
B-: Smithscript Axe
C: Smithscript Shield
Overall, the Smithscript Dagger is the safest all-around pick, while the Cirque is ideal for aggressive players who value speed and mobility. No matter which weapon you choose, having enough Elden Ring Runes can help you level up and optimize your build.
