MLB The Show 25: Complete Guide to the Spooky Advent Program
October is in full swing, and MLB The Show 25 has brought the chills and thrills with its Spooky Program, a limited-time event packed with daily rewards, themed player cards, XP boosts, and surprise treats. Whether you're grinding for Diamond players, Show Packs, or just want to keep your squad fresh with Halloween flair, this program is one of the most rewarding seasonal events yet.
Running from October 17 to October 24, the Spooky Advent Program delivers a new drop every single day, each featuring an exclusive reward — from Diamond players like Craig Kimbrel, Dylan Crews, and Paul Molitor to special packs, XP, and mystery bonuses on the final day.
If you're looking to stay ahead of the curve, maximize your XP, and grab every last treat before the event ends, this complete 1,500-word guide covers everything you need to know about the Spooky Program in MLB The Show 25.
What Is the Spooky Advent Program?
The Spooky Advent Program is a week-long Halloween event where players can unlock daily rewards by logging in, completing missions, or participating in themed challenges. Much like a holiday advent calendar, each date between October 17 and October 24 offers a unique reward that can only be claimed on that day.
Rewards include:
Exclusive player cards (with themed art and unique quirks)
Stubs, XP, and packs to level up faster
Choice Packs and Headliners to upgrade your Diamond Dynasty team
A mystery reward on the final day, October 24
This event isn't just about cosmetics — many of the cards and rewards are playable and highly valuable for teams competing in Ranked Seasons or Conquest modes.
Spooky Advent Program Schedule & Rewards (October 17–24)
Here's a complete day-by-day breakdown of every known reward in the Spooky Program so far:
October 17 – Craig Kimbrel (Diamond)
Reward: 99 OVR Craig Kimbrel (Milestone Series)
Bonus: 5,000 XP + 3x The Show Packs
Theme: "Closing Time — Monster Edition"
The program kicks off with a bang, offering a powerful Craig Kimbrel card based on his dominance as a closer. Kimbrel's Milestone version features elite K/9, velocity, and control stats, making him a must-have bullpen weapon for high-level Diamond Dynasty players.
Tip: Use Kimbrel in Ranked or Events to complete parallel XP missions faster while stacking progress toward future Milestone Program goals.
October 18 – Werewolf Icon Profile Item
Reward: Werewolf Icon cosmetic + Season 6 Choice Pack
Bonus: 5,000 XP + The Show Pack
Theme: "Unleash Your Inner Beast"
This day focuses on flair and customization. Equip the Werewolf Icon to give your profile a Halloween glow-up, and open the Season 6 Choice Pack for a shot at powerful upgrades.
Tip: If you're saving MLB 25 stubs, hold your packs until later in the week — the market tends to dip during multi-day reward events, letting you buy low and sell high.
October 19 – Dylan Crews (Diamond)
Reward: 99 OVR Dylan Crews (Milestone Series)
Bonus: 5,000 XP + 3x The Show Packs
Theme: "The Rookie of the Night"
Dylan Crews steps up as the featured player card for Day 3, bringing elite contact and power vs. right-handers and excellent fielding and speed. This Milestone card is a major addition for center fielders and can anchor your outfield with speed and slugging power.
Recommended Role: Use Crews as your leadoff hitter — his bat control and base-running synergy make him a consistent run producer.
October 20 – New Threads 2.0 (Premier Pack)
Reward: New Threads 2.0 Pack
Bonus: Exclusive uniform set + chance at Diamond cosmetics
Theme: "Dress to Distress"
The midway point of the program brings style and luck. The New Threads 2.0 Pack lets you unlock themed uniforms and cosmetics — perfect for showing off your Halloween spirit on the diamond.
Players who collect all the limited edition uniforms unlock a bonus XP reward, so be sure to equip them for your next few matches.
October 21 – Paul Molitor (Diamond)
Reward: 99 OVR Paul Molitor (Milestone Series)
Bonus: 5,000 XP + 3x The Show Packs
Theme: "Molitor's Midnight Hit Parade"
A beloved legend and contact-hitting machine, Paul Molitor joins the Spooky Program lineup with a 99 OVR Milestone card. This version of Molitor is built around pure bat control, clutch hitting, and balanced infield utility.
With high contact and vision stats and excellent base-running awareness, Molitor is perfect for gap-to-gap hitting lineups.
Tip: Pair Molitor with a high-power bat like Aaron Judge or Shohei Ohtani for a devastating 1-2 punch at the top of your order.
October 22 – Ballplayer Choice Pack
Reward: Ballplayer Choice Pack
Bonus: 5,000 XP + 3x The Show Packs
Theme: "Level Up Your Legend"
Day 6 focuses on player development. The Ballplayer Choice Pack is ideal for upgrading your created player or filling out weak positions with meta options.
Depending on your choice, you can unlock boosts for Power, Speed, or Control archetypes, each suited to different playstyles.
Tip: If you're running a Road to the Show career, this pack accelerates your progress dramatically — use it before your next RTTS session.
October 23 – Mystery Diamond Player
Reward: Diamond Player Card (Unknown)
Bonus: 5,000 XP + 3x The Show Packs
Theme: "Who's Lurking in the Shadows?"
This is where things get interesting. The October 23 reward teases a mystery Diamond player, and the community is buzzing with speculation. The silhouette suggests a pitcher, possibly another Halloween-themed legend or a new Milestone card.
Fans have speculated it could be:
A Randy Johnson Halloween Edition
A Clayton Kershaw flashback
Or a special event version of Shohei Ohtani
Regardless of who it is, expect this drop to be one of the most sought-after in the program.
October 24 – Final Mystery Reward
Reward: ???? (Secret Drop)
Bonus: ????
Theme: "The Grand Finale"
The Spooky Program ends with a final mystery reward, likely a culmination of the week's effort. Players who've claimed every daily reward are expected to unlock a Spooky Bundle, rumored to contain:
1x Guaranteed 99 OVR Choice Pack
10x The Show Packs
15,000 XP bonus
And possibly a unique bat skin or stadium cosmetic
Tip: Log in on October 24 no matter what — even if you missed earlier days, this finale reward is open to all active participants.
How to Progress Through the Spooky Program
The Spooky Advent isn't just about logging in — there are several ways to accelerate your progress and ensure you don't miss a single drop.
1. Log In Daily
Each reward can only be claimed on its designated date. Make sure to log in between 5 PM UTC on one day and 4:59 PM UTC the next to secure your prize.
2. Complete Daily Missions
In addition to the automatic daily reward, themed missions are active each day. Examples include:
Pitch 3 scoreless innings (for the Kimbrel day)
Hit 2 doubles with right-handers (for the Crews day)
Score 5 runs with infielders (for Molitor day)
Completing these missions grants bonus XP and extra The Show Packs.
3. Play Conquest or Mini-Seasons
Grinding Conquest maps or Mini-Seasons games counts toward both XP and mission progress, letting you double-dip for efficiency.
4. Stack XP Multipliers
Equip XP boosts and complete multiple daily missions in a single session to optimize your time. Don't forget to claim parallel XP for featured players — it counts toward overall Spooky Program milestones.
Best Rewards to Prioritize
If you can't participate every day, here's a quick ranking of the most valuable Spooky Program rewards to focus on:
Paul Molitor (Oct 21) – Elite contact hitter, 99 OVR.
Craig Kimbrel (Oct 17) – Top-tier bullpen anchor.
Dylan Crews (Oct 19) – Perfect balance of power and defense.
Mystery Diamond Player (Oct 23) – Likely a new legend.
Final Mystery Reward (Oct 24) – End-of-event bundle, potentially huge XP value.
If you only have time for a few days, prioritize these five — they'll have the biggest long-term impact on your Diamond Dynasty roster.
Market & Economy Tips During the Spooky Program
Events like this cause fluctuations in the in-game market:
Sell duplicates early. As more players claim their daily rewards, card supply spikes and prices drop.
Buy meta cards mid-week. Prices tend to rebound after the event ends.
Save your XP Packs. Opening them during a Double XP event can boost efficiency.
Keep an eye on the Community Market — Spooky Program cards often rise in value once they're no longer available.
Final Tips to Maximize Your Spooky Haul
Play Daily, Even for 10 Minutes: You don't need to grind for hours — simply claiming the reward each day is enough to stack major XP and packs.
Link Rewards with Team Affinity: Some daily drops count toward Team Affinity progress; check your Missions tab.
Use Featured Players for Missions: Kimbrel, Crews, and Molitor will have mission synergies for extra XP.
Stay Tuned for Surprises: SDS has hinted at a Halloween Night flash event on October 24, possibly tied to the final mystery reward.
Final Thoughts
The Spooky Advent Program in MLB The Show 25 perfectly captures the spirit of October — rewarding, mysterious, and a little eerie. Whether you're in it for the exclusive player cards, the XP, or the suspense of what's coming next, this week-long event is one you won't want to miss.
So grab your bat, tighten your gloves, and step up to the plate each day between October 17 and 24. With consistent play and a little luck, you'll walk away with a fully stocked Diamond lineup — and maybe even a few Halloween secrets that make The Show a little more magical this season.
Play daily, swing smart, and claim every treat before the curtain falls — the Spooky Program waits for no one!
MMOexp MLB 25 Team