MLB The Show 26 All-Star Guide:Double Cody Bellinger, 60-Card Collection, and Best Rewards Explained

Summary:

The All-Star content drop in MLB The Show 26 brings a massive wave of new rewards, including two versions of Cody Bellinger, a 60-card collection reward, free choice packs, XP programs, and powerful All-Star player cards. Are you wondering which cards are actually worth chasing, whether the collection grind is worth it, or how to spend your resources efficiently? This guide breaks down the best cards, fastest progression methods, and smart roster-building strategies, with reasonable use of MLB The Show 26 Stubs, to help you get the most value from this update.

1. Double Cody Bellinger Release:Which Version Should You Choose?

The biggest highlight of this update is the arrival of two Cody Bellinger cards with different ratings.

99 Cody Bellinger Strengths:

Elite contact and power;

150 speed rating;

Can play every outfield position;

Also capable at first base;

Excellent offensive and defensive balance.

98 Cody Bellinger Advantages:

Slightly lower attributes;

Similar defensive value;

Much better value for players saving resources.

Key point:If you want the strongest possible lineup, choose the 99 version. If you need efficiency, the 98 version is still a very strong option.

Best for:Players looking to upgrade their outfield or add a complete all-around hitter.

2. 60-Card Collection Challenge:Is MVP Bellinger Worth the Grind?

The biggest long-term goal of this program is unlocking the 2026 All-Star Game MVP Cody Bellinger through the 60-card collection.

Recommended approach:

Collect easy-to-obtain All-Star cards first;

Complete program rewards before buying expensive cards;

Progress missions and collections together.

Key point:The collection requirement is high, but the reward makes it valuable for dedicated players.

Best for:Collectors and competitive players chasing top-tier lineups.

3. Fast Program Progression:Earn Rewards Without Wasting Time

The All-Star program is designed around quick progression.

Main activities include:

Moment challenges;

Pitching missions;

Hitting objectives;

XP progression tasks.

Players do not need to focus heavily on multiplayer modes. Many rewards can be earned through single-player content.

Key point:Complete Moments and basic missions first to maximize rewards with minimal time investment.

Best for:Players who want strong rewards without spending hours grinding.

4. Best All-Star Cards:These Players Deserve Attention

With so many new cards available, some stand out more than others.

Michael Wacha

Effective Sinker + Cutter combination;

Reliable starting pitcher option.

Sedan Rafaela

High contact ability;

Great speed;

Elite defense;

Multiple position flexibility.

Raisel Iglesias

Strong bullpen option;

Effective against both left and right hitters.

Tristan Peters & Yordan Herrera

Balanced offensive and defensive options;

Great choices for improving lineup depth.

Key point:Do not only focus on ratings. Versatility and real gameplay performance matter more.

Best for:Players looking to strengthen weak spots across their roster.

5. Free Choice Packs and Prediction Rewards:Spend Smart

For free choice packs, prioritize players who can immediately improve your lineup.

Recommended choices:

Jordan Walker;

Kyle Schwarber;

High-impact starters for your weakest positions.

For All-Star predictions:

Perfect predictions provide rare rewards;

Partial success still gives valuable packs.

Key point:Do not chase collection numbers blindly. Improve your actual lineup first.

6. Final Breakdown:Who Benefits Most From This Update?

New players:Quickly build a stronger roster through free rewards and program cards.

Casual players:Improve team depth without heavy grinding or spending.

Hardcore players:Push collections and target elite cards like MVP Bellinger, with reasonable use of cheap MLB 26 Stubs.

The biggest value of the All-Star update is not just one superstar card-it is the huge amount of roster improvement opportunities across every position.

Extra Tips:

Finish program rewards before investing heavily into collections.

Prioritize cards that can immediately enter your starting lineup.

Multi-position players provide more roster flexibility.

Calculate collection costs before spending resources.